My car had a similar problem. It wouldn't start properly - I would have to step on the gas to start it - and if I didn't give it enough gas to start, it would die on me when I step on the brakes. I assumed it was the alternator, but the first mechanics I took my car to argued that it was my battery. My dad swears that they're so darn great so AGAINST my will, my car battery was replaced. My car's issue did NOT improve. Out of anger, I took it to a shop one of my friends trusted to have the alternator replaced. My car was BETTER, but it was still being an occasional b!tch so I took it to the shop again. Turned out it was a "defective idle air control valve". Had that replaced. Now my car is in excellent condition.
Sucks I spent so darn much (IMG:
style_emoticons/default/sad.gif) but I'm absolutely ecstatic that my car's working beautifully. Proved my dad wrong. Ha!
Btw, the frikn alternator was EXPENSIVE!!! *looks for an "omfg smiley" of some sort* Dude... You guys need more smilies.